WI BIMMERS Facebook group?
-
The R3V page is an absolute joke.
Understatement of the year.
-
I believe I was the one who asked the original question.
I asked it for this reason:
When I move from place to place, the easiest way for me to meet people and find enthusiast groups and information is a search on facebook. In Georgia we have 3 Bimmer groups who intermingle via facebook. These pages haven't gone to shit due to the group actually having an official committee that decides rules and regulations by votes.
When I moved here, it took me well over a month before being told by a friend of a friend that this group existed.
Also facebook groups are useful because I can receive notifications for posts and have quick access to questions/ help/ advice/ advertisements ect. I spend most of my day logged into facebook however I don't use it for anything but updates and news such as this.
I think it would be an excellent idea for a BMW club to have a social media presence. This way I can get to know people personally before actually meeting them by friending and viewing personal content about them. Buying items off them would also be easier by messenger and other features offered. Personally I come to forums for big information gathering needs that would best be suited here. However I never post on just our small state forum alone, I also keep an active presence on Bimmerforums and 1addics. That being said that doesn't take away from my participation in ATLBimmers/ FloridaBimmers/ Bimmerforums/ 1addicts.
It just provides quicker options for information and help to me. I also think it helps the average BMW driver isn't under 18 years of age or something like that.
-
I like the format of forums better than FB. Seems it is much more difficult to have meaningful/searchable/quality conversations on FB.
Well that's two words you never see associated with FB.
-
I'm certainly not opposed to a FB group (I would join and post awesome memes and car pics with the best of them), I just don't really see the allure other then to attract new "people" (which I personal think isn't always a good thing).
As a reference, here's "Collins Recap" of the 12 more recent Posts on the R3V FB page:
"I don't know where to find parts or how to fix my issue"
"Check out this video link I stole from someone else's page"
"Buy my Parts"
"Look at Me - Look at Me!"
"Look at Me - Look at Me!"
"Check out this picture I stole from someone else's page"
"Look at Me - Look at Me!"
"Check out this link I found to parts for sale"
"Someone tell me what I should like"
"Look at Me - Look at Me!"
"Check out this link I found to parts for sale"
"I don't know where to find parts or how to fix my issue"
I apologize if it seems like I'm an judge mental asshole - but this is the internet and it's serious business.
Also - Snaps not on FB..... So.... There's that.
-
I'm not opposed to a Facebook page necessarily, but, it will definitely have a negative effect on forum participation. I'm a member of a forum for my other collector car, which also has a Facebook page. Participation on the forum has all but vanished in the past year except for a few of us die hards. If everybody feels that a Facebook page would be fun, go for it. Just don't be surprised if participation here takes a serious nose dive.
Just my
-
I'm not opposed to a Facebook page necessarily, but, it will definitely have a negative effect on forum participation. I'm a member of a forum for my other collector car, which also has a Facebook page. Participation on the forum has all but vanished in the past year except for a few of us die hards. If everybody feels that a Facebook page would be fun, go for it. Just don't be surprised if participation here takes a serious nose dive.
Just my
That's exactly what we don't want to happen, seems like new people would just be drawn to Facebook postings over visiting the site.
-
OK first my diclaimer:
I in no way intend to be condescending or an ass hole in this post.
Restricting a group means of communication to a forum in an age of social media just feels a little old fart ish. What does that mean? Well there is a whole world out there outside of WI. I understand we are WI Bimmers but no other Bimmer group will ever be aware of our existence unless they search this exact forum and name via Google which probably isn't even the first result.
New members? How is that a bad thing? In my experience the more members you have the more possible participants you will have for you meets and events. 100 members total and a forum = 100 forum members. 500 members and 30% forum participation = 150 forum members. It's a numbers game and if the younger members like me 25 and under find it easier to communicate and participate on a daily I don't see the harm. It already feels like your events and meets are to largely spaced out due to the choir of having to come to this forum page and hope that members login to read about the meets. That means you have to place meets to far in the future that people have the time to see it and respond.
Meaningful information?
I don't know about you but I don't always do things for meaningful and practicality, what ever happened to fun? It kind of feels like you want to push a high society organization by not being open minded to the 16 year old who just traded his honda for his first bimmer. Why yes this members i very annoying, immature and probably going to be for the next 4-6 years of his life but how is he supposed to learn he isn't suppose to use the red or green coolant in his 15 year old BMW unless we ridicule him and give him the good old meme beat down for trashing his cooling system?
Sorry if this turned into a rant but here are some pictures of a functioning LARGE bimmer group in Georgia.
you may draw your opinions from these and roast my post if you so feel. No feelings will be hurt lol
-
OK first my diclaimer:
I in no way intend to be condescending or an ass hole in this post.
Restricting a group means of communication to a forum in an age of social media just feels a little old fart ish. What does that mean? Well there is a whole world out there outside of WI. I understand we are WI Bimmers but no other Bimmer group will ever be aware of our existence unless they search this exact forum and name via Google which probably isn't even the first result.
New members? How is that a bad thing? In my experience the more members you have the more possible participants you will have for you meets and events. 100 members total and a forum = 100 forum members. 500 members and 30% forum participation = 150 forum members. It's a numbers game and if the younger members like me 25 and under find it easier to communicate and participate on a daily I don't see the harm. It already feels like your events and meets are to largely spaced out due to the choir of having to come to this forum page and hope that members login to read about the meets. That means you have to place meets to far in the future that people have the time to see it and respond.
Meaningful information?
I don't know about you but I don't always do things for meaningful and practicality, what ever happened to fun? It kind of feels like you want to push a high society organization by not being open minded to the 16 year old who just traded his honda for his first bimmer. Why yes this members i very annoying, immature and probably going to be for the next 4-6 years of his life but how is he supposed to learn he isn't suppose to use the red or green coolant in his 15 year old BMW unless we ridicule him and give him the good old meme beat down for trashing his cooling system?
Sorry if this turned into a rant but here are some pictures of a functioning LARGE bimmer group in Georgia.
you may draw your opinions from these and roast my post if you so feel. No feelings will be hurt lol
You... You make a compelling argument.
-
You... You make a compelling argument.
I agree and as I stated early my argument FOR a Facebook page was to attract new members. My doubt's were the turnover rate of page members to the forum.
I have more to say but much lunch is over lol.
-
No matter what I seem to type with this post - I either sound like a condescending pompous ass - or an old man.....
So make the damn FB page already. I don't have nearly enough sketchy CL ads links, cat pics, and "Zomg - Look at Me!" Posts on my feed right now anyways.
-
Forums are for enthusiasts and Facebook pages are for schmucks.
The format of going through status's and comments is utterly inferior to the usage of threads on Forums. Navigation and formality of a forum is why they will always prevail over Facebook groups.
WiBimmers already has a Facebook page where people can join and find out about our Forum. I see no reason to make that page mimic this glorious website.
-
I agree with stuff
I am also a pompous ass.
I want to share my passion/hobby with others, and help them enjoy it as much as I do.
I have a distinct fear of a local forum where the majority consists of current model year bmws fresh off the lot and the threads consist of which dealer is best for installing ///M floor mats and license plate frames.
I also start a lot of sentences with the word "I"
-
No matter what I seem to type with this post - I either sound like a condescending pompous ass - or an old man.....
So make the damn FB page already. I don't have nearly enough sketchy CL ads links, cat pics, and "Zomg - Look at Me!" Posts on my feed right now anyways.
-
(Here comes the asshole in me)
But what about the deep seeded issues of today's youth constantly clamoring for any sense of approval or acknowledgement from their peers?!? Without those 34 "Likes" on their FB page and IG - they don't feel the constant approval of others like through their childhood full of participation awards and group hugs?
-
When can we add a "poke" function to the forum.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login